735 Hawkins Ave
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
Phaya-plus
Phayathai is a hidden treasure right near the LIE in an unassuming shopping mall. The only sign you see from the road is the word THAI. I’ve been going to this place for over two years, if you’re looking for a place to get consistently good Thai food, this is it. The pad thai (I usually get chicken, but the tofu-vegetable is also good) is always outstanding, it’s usually accompanied by shredded carrot, red cabbage and chopped peanuts. If it’s not, it might not be a good sign. Mix in some pepper flakes, and it is the perfect balance between sweet and spicy. For an appetizer I recommend the vegetable spring rolls, Thai-style dumplings or fried calamari. Michael likes the fish cakes but I think they’re a little too rubbery.
Honorable mention goes to the pad si ew (flat noodles with broccoli, egg and a brown sauce) with tofu.
Desserts are typically what you would find in a Thai restaurant with special mention going to the fried banana with ice cream. If you’re lucky, and it’s around New Years, maybe they’ll put a sparkler in it for you. You never know what fun to expect at Phayathai.
Phaya-minus
On the down side, the summer roll (bean curd, bean sprout, cellophane noodle, cucumber, carrot, basil and scallion wrapped in rice skin) was disappointing and had a strange taste. Also, the Thai iced tea is sickeningly sweet and overpowering, but Michael likes it. Personally, I’d stick with the water.
Overall
I know this place has had some financial trouble in the past year and the area can’t afford to lose one of the best Thai places on Long Island. So if you’re looking to support a locally owned business, this place is for you. The place family owned and they’re very friendly and often stop by for a brief chat. Service can be a little slow but that allows for a leisurely meal. The prices are average, although you will want to use cash since their credit card machine has a tendency to mess up the charges.
One word of caution: eat in! Take out just doesn’t taste as good. It lacks flavor and seems a little gummy. But if you eat in, you’re be sure to get a great meal.
-9.5/10-
The Tofu Pad See Ew (Back) and Chicken Pad Thai (Front)
-Ryan
